Cut to the Feeling: An Argument for Honesty

Write what you know is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard. 

                                                                                    — Kazuo Ishiguro, Literary Hub

In the literary world, the common consensus is this: honesty is overrated.

We’ve moved past confessionalism, outgrown recklessness — know better than to bleed out on the page. And, most importantly, we’ve swallowed whole the advice any well-intentioned mentor has fed us at some point or another and never, ever write what we know. 

But why?

I could begin with the publishers, the competitions. Or how nuance never exists in the extremes. I could begin by telling you that things like love, sorrow, joy — these common experiences are just that: common.

But instead, I’ll begin by saying why not?

Sometimes, I’ll read a poem so thick in metaphor that I can’t help, but call the technique unproductive. Sometimes, the truth is best served plain like in Czesław Miłosz’s Gift [see below].

Miłosz’s frank sincerity is so refreshing. He writes the way one would write a diary entry. He doesn’t perform — there are no acrobatics, the poem doesn’t set itself on fire.

Miłosz is honest — his poem doesn’t care for the reader’s gaze.

Who’s to say we should write for others and not ourselves. In our writing, perhaps we should prioritize the self, our own emotions.

Or, as Carly Rae Jepsen would put it: cut to the feeling.


One Reply to “Cut to the Feeling: An Argument for Honesty”

  1. I feel you on the “what is wrong with just being honest?” thing. Now, when I think of “honesty,” I think of “bluntness,” even though those two terms aren’t really the same thing. One can be honest without being blunt (although it would be difficult to be blunt and not honest). Honest poetry is not necessarily blunt… Wait, can bluntness be poetic? Damn, I’m gonna be awake all night now…

    Anyway, I do think there is a place for the acrobatic, convoluted stuff, too. But we can have everything in moderation, right?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.